Skip to main content

Table 2 Categories, indicators and illustrative quotations for social presence

From: Community of Inquiry framework to evaluate an online obstetric and neonatal emergency simulation workshop for health professional students in India

Categories

Indicators

Example quotation

Open communication

Risk free expression

1. “Doctors should communicate with nurses with respect.” M5

2. “We are able to learn how to work with our colleagues, know that everyone is equally important despite their rank and to speak up even in front of seniors.” N11

Flattening traditional hierarchical communication

3. “In some places there is no communication between nurses and doctors. Because of this patient outcomes suffer. It is good to conduct workshops together and learn how to share our experience with doctors” M51

4. “An inter-professional workshop like this helps us to know the importance of each team member irrespective of qualification. Doctors and nurses work together and this helps everyone speak up despite their rank” N21

Affective expression

Emotions

5. “Performing procedures in an emergency in real life is scary” M52

6. “I felt scared and panicky at the start” N1

Staying calm

7. “I learned how to control my fear and stay calm on the outside” M13

8. “Staying calm is an important leadership quality. When the leader is calm and confident, everyone else also feels confident” N21

Communicating emotional response

9. “When there is an emergency, I get very nervous and make mistakes. I should let my team know this so that they can help me do my job better” M48

10. “I have learned from this workshop how to communicate with my team when I am unsure of what to do” N44

Group cohesion

Encourage collaboration

11. “Everyone involved has a role to play and it is important to merge different ideas and cooperate with each other.” M33

12. “In any emergency, it is important that skilled people from multiple professions work together to coordinate all the tasks.” N18

Valuing collective effort over individual “heroism”

13. “Teamwork is important to achieve good outcomes. One person can’t do all the work at the same time” M27

14. “Doctors, nurses and other staff make one big team. Without any one of them the structure would weaken as they are all pillars which uphold good patient care” N6

15. “Saving a life is not a job anyone can do single-handedly” N33

Team preparedness

16. “Planning and preparing before carrying out any procedure and appointing people best suited for specific tasks is the first priority” M10

17. “Simulation is the best way I have learnt to recognise all team members are adequately prepared for all possible emergencies” N82

Team culture/relationships

18. “This (workshop) will help me improve my interpersonal skills. This will help in forming trusting relationships” M4

19. “Doing this workshop helps form a bond between medical and nursing staff. Trusting your teammates is important” N67